Why did God put the Infinity Stones in the universe? I don’t mean the Marvel universe but our own. As the Marvel world winds down, Stan is dead, many loose ends are wrapped up and the last movies is called ‘Endgame’, it won’t be the same going forward, the magic is gone. But some of the magic that made this world work were the Infinity Stones. Gems which contained complete power over certain aspects of the world; space, mind, reality, power, time, soul. In Infinity War the bad guy gets them all and is basically all powerful, in a Malthusian move he wipes out half of the life in the universe, in a failed attempt to solve the economic problem of scarcity. Now this sub-created world isn’t as morally accurate or as good, in the real sense of the word, as say Tolkien’s world. But in order to hold sway with so many it must contain certain connections to the truth. So why these ridiculously powerful objects? Obviously it makes these stories better, which is not unlike our world.
In our world, also known as reality, the Infinity Stones are more like ideas, really bad ideas. From the start they were questions no one had asked before with devastating consequences. “Did God actually say, ‘You shall not eat of any tree in the garden’?”. Then we are off to the races, the bad idea creeps in and is embodied in the fruit, the apple, or pandora’s box, various forms in various literatures. But wouldn’t the world have been better if no one had asked the question? Apparently not. Why do bad things happen? We often wonder while they happen to us. Yet we all flock to the theater to watch them happen. How many people went to see Titanic? One of the worse sea disasters of all time. Asking bad questions makes good stories. When everyone does what they are supposed to and there is no possibility of failure, there is no story. Which is why Captain Marvel is so lame. After the garden God placed angels with fiery swords to keep humans from solidifying their sin by making it eternal, by partaking in another object, the tree of life. Bad questions are generally just testing the opposite of what God said. And they piled up into a huge flood of sin that wiped out most of the world, save Noah. Then they piled up again in the great tower of Babel, as men tried congregating instead of spreading and filling the earth. God resets the world again. It continues generating bad ideas; “maybe we should sacrifice our children?” “virgins?”. But from now on God only pulls out a small remnant. And there seems to be cycles. Why does God allow these ideas of such immense destruction?
Each bad idea, each Infinity Stone asks a bad question and posits a fake Messiah as the solution. In 1798 Thomas Malthus, wrote an essay laying out the philosophy of Thanos. War and famine were necessary to balance out the people vs. resources equation. Since these were going away in the modern world other steps would be necessary to balance the equation. This thinking lead to modern catastrophes such as eugenics, championed by Hitler and the lesser known founder of Planned Parenthood Margaret Sanger. They were trying to balance the equation.
In 1848 Karl Marx ask his stupid question. Was the problem with the world really all about economic disparity? If only we could crash capitalism, Christianity and the Family we would reset the system and all live happily ever after. The dark red armies marching the earth in pursuit of this insane question, have killed hundreds of millions of people. Communist famines, wars and death camps made the 20th century the bloodies in human history.
In 1852 while the Communist Manifesto was still hot off the presses, Harriet Beecher Stowe asked a similar questions. Maybe the problems of the world were due to slavery? Her misrepresentations and overstatements of southern slavery in a work of complete fiction, kicked off much of the strife we now see to this day in the US. The radical abolitionists went on to undermine the Biblical and legal foundations of our nation, and the reverberations spread around the world. The resulting war killed close to a million men and actually made race relations worse. Rather than patiently working out the issue with talking in government, we took to arms. North vs. South, the Klan, Black Panthers, marches, demonstrations. Shows of force instead of political discussions. And now we have all the piggy back movements, everyone wants to be repressed minorities, LGBTQWERTY.
Shortly after Darwin asked his question. Did God really say he created each according to his kind? Perhaps kinds just turned into other kinds. Perhaps their was no God, just metamorphosis. His question led to the further devaluing of life. Humans were not special, we just happened. Forces and Nature had conspired randomly to drive this extreme pragmatism. Our task was really to further this happening, this survival of the fittest. Hitler took up this mantle too and millions more died.
Well that didn’t work out so well. Maybe the problem was really your parents and repressed sexual desire. Sigmund Freud asked all sorts of insane questions placing blame everywhere but upon you. There was no original sin, the heart was not desperately wicked. Men are good made bad by their parents. So don’t repent, blame someone else. He may not be responsible for millions dying, but he is responsible for enslaving the modern world in bitterness, anger, envy, jealousy, and a myriad of sexual perversions. He undermined truth as it applies to self discipline, all the virtues and criminal law. He kicked off all sorts of destructive projects from asylums to drugs to electroshock techniques. Science had given us machines. So let’s apply that science to men and fix everything.
The last of the six stones was The Feminine Mystique. This bad question asked by Betty Friedan was “Is sex just a social construct?” The problem with the world doesn’t have anything to do with sin, it’s all about women being forced into subservient positions. The problem was Paul telling women to love their wives and their husbands. And the solution was walking out on your kids and your husband and the white picket fence and having free sex in the mud at Woodstock. And if sex is a social construct so is marriage, so I can marry whomever I want. I can even choose my own sex, or invent new genders. And the disease and social chaos continue to this moment. Many of us are so wrapped up in it we don’t even notice. Because this evil is now the enslaving social construct Friedan purported to shatter.
But why does God allow all this to happen. Why not keep the lid on pandora’s box? It’s almost like that isn’t good enough. It’s like that conversation with Peter by the lake. Do you love me? Do you love me in a world where you have to love me? Will you choose to do what I say in a world where there are only two options? How about 5 options? How about 50 options? Will you repent despite all the excuses given by the above people? It’s easy to follow Biblical tradition when everyone is doing it. But will you marry and treat your marriage roles as I have created them, male and female, in a world where everyone is making up new rebellions to my order? Will you keep your long hair and submit to your husband when no one else is? Will you work hard and lay down your life to protect your wife from all the snakes in the garden offering lies? Will you raise your kids to walk in my way? It’s easy when the free public schools are doing most of it for you. But will you choose it when it’s not popular? When it’s expensive? The Church of late has almost obsessed with the notion of chosen good. We over emphasize our choice so much because, deep down we “hate the idea that we are not in control of our lives”. And so we have stopped coming alongside our brother, we have stopped correcting those in error. We have stopped holding the world to account for it’s evil. We don’t rule the fool with the rod. We think the presence of the rod is an indicator of a problem not a form of the solution. Yet we do the same thing in many areas, we forbid alcohol, we make arbitrary limits on all sorts of areas of life where God does not. And in addition we succumb to the power of these bad questions, these Infinity Stones. Part of this is correct. God made a world with the potential for incredible destructions, from small ideas, mind objects, idols. He gave us enough rope to hang ourselves, and everyone else. The world is dangerous and risky. In some ways pressing on despite the tide of growing evil is a greater love. It requires much wisdom, which is sorely lacking. Often we enable sin, cause these little ones to stumble unnecessarily. We don’t train them to fight, to obey in the face of these new growing forces. We need to ease children into these risks not protect them in a bubble. Yet often when they are older and they do stray we need to pull out the rod and correct, bring back that lost sheep. Narrow the field of options a little. If not, woe to us for causing the sin.
So I wonder about all these things, as I think about how our universe winds down. What is God’s endgame? It seems very clear that the Gospel has been remaking the world for the past 2000 years. No more remnant, every knee shall bow. Much has changed, paganism with its cannibalism and child sacrifice are gone, but in a sense they are not. The gospel has divided men of every tongue tribe and nation. The truth has been put to them in the sea of lies and they have made their commitment by the Spirit. The false world marches down the road to inevitability, getting ever more ticked off that it lost at the cross. All it can do is ask more dumb questions. Use the Stones for evil because it must. Their raging will grow louder but they won’t win. American Christians have fallen into the inevitable pit themselves, by saying “in the end times things will get worse”. But that was meant for 1st century Jews trying to decide whether to rebel against Rome or follow Jesus. Those who followed Jesus lived. And today following Jesus to life is similar, do what he says, remake the world. They may have the infinity stones. But we have a leader who came back from the dead. He his now seated and ruling in heaven. People who ignore that are inevitable, but they are also a joke. We are laughing at them. We have the ultimate weapon, we can lay down our lives.
Further Reading: Pereladra, C. S. Lewis